My accountant wants $5,000 more to cut my bill. Is that normal?
Answered from IRS pages, checked November 2026A flat or hourly fee for tax planning can be normal, if it does not depend on how much tax you save1. A fee set as a share of your savings is a contingent fee, which Circular 230 bars for tax planning1.
Is this fee normal?
- A flat fee for a written tax plan1Can be normal
- Hourly billing for planning work1Normal
- A percentage of the tax you save (a contingent fee)1Not allowed
- Pay first, see the plan laterGet the scope in writing
- Savings that need an S-corp, which must pay you a reasonable salary first5Check the numbers first
Next steps
tedthetaxguy.com/accountant-fee-to-cut-my-taxes · General information, not tax advice. Ted is an AI, not a CPA or EA.
Ask Ted about this fee
Hi, I'm Ted, a free AI tax guide. I explain US tax rules with IRS sources, and I'll tell you when it's worth talking to a real tax pro. I'm an AI, not a CPA or EA, so this is general information, not tax advice. What's on your mind?
Key numbers
Common questions
Is there a limit on what an accountant can charge?
Is a fee based on my tax savings ever allowed?
Yes, for help when the IRS examines or challenges your return, for court cases, and for refund claims only about IRS interest or penalties1. The exam rule covers an amended return or refund claim filed within 120 days of a written exam notice1. A promise to refund your fee if the IRS challenges the savings is a contingent fee too1.
Did a court limit the contingent fee rule?
Who has to follow this rule?
How do I report a preparer?
Sources
- IRS, Treasury Department Circular No. 230: Regulations Governing Practice before the Internal Revenue Service (Rev. 6-2014)
- U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia (GovInfo), Gerald Lee Ridgely, Jr. v. Jacob J. Lew, et al., Memorandum Opinion (Civil Action No. 1:12-cv-00565)
- Treasury Department (Federal Register), Regulations Governing Practice Before the Internal Revenue Service
- IRS, Tax return preparer misconduct
- IRS, S corporation compensation and medical insurance issues
- IRS, Understanding tax return preparer credentials and qualifications
Checked November 2026
General information, not tax advice. Ted is an AI tax guide, not a CPA or EA.
Your situation is different? Ask Ted.
The page answers the general question. Ted answers yours, from the same IRS pages.