Skip to the main content
Ted is an AI tax guide, not a CPA or EA
Ted is an AI tax guide, not a CPA or EA

My accountant wants $5,000 more to cut my bill. Is that normal?

Answered from IRS pages, checked November 2026

A flat or hourly fee for tax planning can be normal, if it does not depend on how much tax you save1. A fee set as a share of your savings is a contingent fee, which Circular 230 bars for tax planning1.

Checklist

Is this fee normal?

  • A flat fee for a written tax plan1Can be normal
  • Hourly billing for planning work1Normal
  • A percentage of the tax you save (a contingent fee)1Not allowed
  • Pay first, see the plan laterGet the scope in writing
  • Savings that need an S-corp, which must pay you a reasonable salary first5Check the numbers first
How we got this

The verdicts follow the fee rules in Circular 230, sections 10.27 and 10.301. A 2014 court ruling limits the contingent fee ban for refund claims filed before an audit2. A 2024 Treasury proposal would replace section 10.27 once final rules are published3.

Printing shows only this card

Ask Ted about this fee

Hi, I'm Ted, a free AI tax guide. I explain US tax rules with IRS sources, and I'll tell you when it's worth talking to a real tax pro. I'm an AI, not a CPA or EA, so this is general information, not tax advice. What's on your mind?

Start with this page's question

Key numbers

  • Rule that bars fees based on tax savedCircular 230, section 10.271Any tax year
  • Exception window after a written exam notice120 days1Any tax year
  • Court ruling that limits the ruleJul 16, 20142Any tax year
  • Form to report a preparerForm 141574Any tax year

Common questions

Is there a limit on what an accountant can charge?

Circular 230 bars an unconscionable fee, but it sets no dollar limit1. A practitioner who publishes fee rates cannot charge more than those rates for at least 30 days after publishing them1.

Is a fee based on my tax savings ever allowed?

Yes, for help when the IRS examines or challenges your return, for court cases, and for refund claims only about IRS interest or penalties1. The exam rule covers an amended return or refund claim filed within 120 days of a written exam notice1. A promise to refund your fee if the IRS challenges the savings is a contingent fee too1.

Did a court limit the contingent fee rule?

In 2014 a federal court ruled the IRS cannot enforce it for refund claims filed after your return but before an audit2. It found that simply preparing and filing such a claim is not practice before the IRS2. Treasury notes the court did not rule on other contingent fees3.

Who has to follow this rule?

Circular 230 applies to practitioners, such as CPAs, attorneys and enrolled agents1. Those three credentials carry unlimited rights to represent you before the IRS6. A preparer with only a PTIN, no other credential and no Annual Filing Season Program record cannot represent you6.

How do I report a preparer?

Use Form 14157, Return Preparer Complaint, to report a preparer's misconduct to the IRS4. For excess fees paid for return preparation, the IRS points you to the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration instead4. The IRS asks for specific, credible facts, not guesses4.

General information, not tax advice. Ted is an AI tax guide, not a CPA or EA.

Your situation is different? Ask Ted.

The page answers the general question. Ted answers yours, from the same IRS pages.

Or ask it for your situation:

General information, not tax advice.