Does an LLC save taxes over a sole proprietorship?
Answered from IRS pages, checked November 2026No: for income tax, a one-owner LLC with no election is taxed like a sole proprietorship: Schedule C and the same 15.3% self-employment tax123. Its main tax extra is the option to be taxed as a C-corp or S-corp later, and state fees can make it cost more145.
One-owner LLC vs sole proprietorship: what changes
- Federal income tax with 1 owner and no election2Same: Schedule C on your Form 1040
- Self-employment tax on your net earnings3Same: 15.3%
- The 20% qualified business income deduction2Same, and permanent
- Electing to be taxed as a corporation (Form 8832) or an S-corp (Form 2553)4Needs an entity, like an LLC
- Hiring employees1The LLC is the employer, with its own EIN
- Delaware: a $400 annual tax on every LLC formed or registered there, due by Jun 15Extra state cost
- New York: a $25 yearly IT-204-LL fee for a 1-owner LLC with New York source income6Extra state cost
- Texas: a 1-owner LLC is a franchise taxable entity, but a sole proprietor without liability protection is not7Subject to franchise tax
Next steps
tedthetaxguy.com/llc-vs-sole-proprietorship-taxes · General information, not tax advice. Ted is an AI, not a CPA or EA.
Ask Ted about LLC vs sole proprietorship taxes
Hi, I'm Ted, a free AI tax guide. I explain US tax rules with IRS sources, and I'll tell you when it's worth talking to a real tax pro. I'm an AI, not a CPA or EA, so this is general information, not tax advice. What's on your mind?
Key numbers for 2026
- Federal income tax difference, 1 owner and no electionNone1Any tax year
- Self-employment tax rate, either way15.3%3Any tax year
- Qualified business income deduction, either way20%, now permanent2Tax year 2026
- Delaware annual tax on an LLC$4005Any tax year
- New York IT-204-LL fee, 1-owner LLC with New York source income$256Any tax year
With 1 owner, the federal income tax is the same
A sole proprietor is someone who owns an unincorporated business alone2. If you are the only member of an LLC and never elect corporate treatment, you are a sole proprietor for income tax purposes too2. The LLC is disregarded, and its income and deductions go on your own return12.
So you file the same Schedule C and pay the same 15.3% self-employment tax, once your net earnings reach $40023. Schedule C income may qualify for the qualified business income deduction either way2. The 2025 law made that 20% deduction permanent for qualified active trades or businesses2.
The main tax extra: you can elect later
An LLC can file Form 8832 to be taxed as a corporation1. A corporation, or an entity eligible to be taxed as one, can file Form 2553 to be an S-corp if it passes the tests4. A sole proprietorship is an unincorporated business, so you'd form an entity first to use either one24.
Form 2553 is due no more than 2 months and 15 days after the start of the tax year it should take effect4. You can also file it any time in the tax year before that year4.
State fees are the real cost difference
Your state can charge an LLC fees or taxes that a sole proprietorship doesn't pay567. Delaware charges every LLC formed or registered there a $400 annual tax, due by Jun 1, with a $200 penalty if late5. New York charges a 1-owner LLC with New York source income a $25 yearly fee on Form IT-204-LL6.
Texas treats a 1-owner LLC as a franchise taxable entity, even when it files as a sole proprietor for federal tax7. A sole proprietorship not organized to limit its liability is not a taxable entity7.
What the LLC changes when you hire
Even with 1 owner, the LLC counts as its own entity for employment tax and certain excise taxes1. If it has employees, it needs its own EIN1. Without employees or those excise taxes, it generally uses your name and taxpayer ID for federal tax1.
Common questions
What are the tax advantages of an LLC?
Does an LLC lower my self-employment tax?
Do I still get the 20% QBI deduction with an LLC?
Does a single-member LLC file its own tax return?
Sources
- IRS, Single member limited liability companies
- IRS, Publication 334 (2025), Tax Guide for Small Business
- IRS, Self-employment tax (Social Security and Medicare taxes)
- IRS, Instructions for Form 2553 (12/2020)
- Delaware Division of Corporations, LLC/LP/GP Franchise Tax Instructions
- New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, Partnership, LLC, and LLP annual filing fee
- Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts, Franchise Tax Frequently Asked Questions: Taxable Entities
Checked November 2026
General information, not tax advice. Ted is an AI tax guide, not a CPA or EA.
Your situation is different? Ask Ted.
The page answers the general question. Ted answers yours, from the same IRS pages.